Blood In The Water? | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Airborne On ANN

Airborne 04.27.15

Airborne 04.21.15

Airborne 04.22.15

Airborne 04.23.15

Airborne 04.24.15

Airborne Hi-Def On YouTube

Airborne 04.27.15

Airborne 04.21.15

Airborne 04.22.15

Airborne 04.23.15

Airborne 04.24.15

Thu, Apr 22, 2004

Blood In The Water?

AOPA Pressing FAA To Drop Charity/Sightseeing Rule

The FAA's proposal to force small sightseeing businesses to meet the requirements for large air tour operators and increase flight-time requirements for pilots who fly charity fund-raisers is neither justified nor supported by safety data and should be withdrawn, AOPA told the agency on Monday.

In AOPA's formal response, filed on what was to have been the last day of public comment, Senior Vice President of Government and Technical Affairs Andy Cebula said that by combining sightseeing, air tours, and charity flights, the FAA has made the proposal "impractical, if not impossible, to implement.

"This also reflects a failure by the FAA to understand the uses of general aviation aircraft."

AOPA says the FAA's claims that the proposed rule will improve safety are suspect.

"Nothing in the original Federal Register notice or the information that has been made available during the comment period indicates that there is a significant safety issue with sightseeing flights," Cebula wrote. The AOPA Air Safety Foundation reviewed the 73 accidents mentioned in supporting documents for the NPRM and found that in 92 percent of those cases, the proposed rule would not have prevented the accidents. The other eight percent only might have been prevented if operated as Part 135 flights.

The proposal to increase the minimum number of hours a private pilot must have in order to provide sightseeing flights to help charities raise money is arbitrary and would do little to improve safety, argued AOPA. Raising the minimum from 200 to 500 hours would mean 22% fewer pilots would be available to help charities raise money. Private pilots are limited to four such events per year. The flights must be conducted in day VFR conditions and are typically flown near the pilot's home in an area with which they're thoroughly familiar.

As Cebula noted in AOPA's comments, more than a dozen members of Congress expressed concerns about the proposed rule's adverse economic impact on the GA community in letters to the FAA. And the Office of Advocacy at the government's own Small Business Administration also found the FAA's economic data seriously flawed and recommended that the NPRM be withdrawn.

After the FAA initially published its notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM), AOPA conducted its own survey and analysis of the proposal's safety and economic impact and found the agency grossly underestimated the true effects. AOPA petitioned the FAA to hold public meetings and hear directly from the pilots who would be harmed. Late last week, five months after the initial petition, the FAA finally granted AOPA's petition and announced that it would hold two public meetings in May.

The NPRM not only harms Part 91 sightseeing businesses and charity fund-raiser flights, it also imposes significant hardships on existing Part 135 air tour operators. The proposal would require expensive new equipment and adopt standards that would result in far more frequent weather cancellations.

"One Alaska operator estimates the cost to their company at $15 million to $18 million over a 10-year period," wrote Cebula.

"AOPA strongly opposes the NPRM and requests that the FAA withdraw the NPRM immediately," he concluded.

FMI: www.aopa.org, www.media.aopa.org/sfo_final.asx, www.media.aopa.org/AK_sightseeing.asx

Advertisement

More News

AOPA Asks FAA To Close Gaps In UAS Rule

Calls NPRM A 'Good First Step Towards Integration' AOPA is asking the FAA to close 'gaps' in the agency’s proposed rules governing small commercial unmanned aircraft systems >[...]

Classic Aero-TV: Adventure Of A Lifetime -- Around The World by MU-2

OK... Admit It -- Wouldn't You Have Loved To Fly In This Adventure? In this video ANN CEO and Editor-In-Chief, Jim Campbell brings us an adventure story. While at the NBAA 2013 con>[...]

Airborne 04.27.15: EAA/Sonex, Ryanair v Biofuel, Sportys' 172Lite

Also: Super Sabre@Oshkosh!!!, A380's 10th, All About That Space, UAV Problem In Japan, Siemens Electric Aero-Propulsion, New Caravan Interiors The Gathering of Eagles is an event h>[...]

House Armed Services Committee Would Cut KC-46, LRS-B

Draft Budget Takes $460 Million From Next-Generation Bomber Program A draft military budget which will be discussed by the House Armed Services Committee (HASC) this week would cut>[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Linx (04.28.15)

All the World's Rotorcraft Started in 1997 by an aviation enthusiast in Estonia, the site claims to be "the biggest helicopter collection in the world, more than 700 helicopters an>[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus



Advertisement

Advertisement

Podcasts

Advertisement

© 2007 - 2015 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC